Media Mention

Kimberly Melvin Remarks on Supreme Court Review of Securities Fraud Litigation

Business Insurance
January 16, 2011

Insurance Practice partner Kimberly Melvin was quoted commenting on a U.S. Supreme Court decision to review a case involving securities fraud litigation.  As the article reports, the case “involves what a plaintiff has to prove before it can obtain class certification on its claims”—which in this particular lawsuit involves allegations against Halliburton that it misrepresented its asbestos liabilities. A panel of judges of the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals “held plaintiffs to a higher standard of proof concerning losses than many other circuits,” according to legal experts. “It’s important to understand that what the Supreme Court holds as the actual standard may be more important than the resolution of the case,” Ms. Melvin said. “The guidance given to the district courts about the level of scrutiny of the merits—especially the loss causation issue—will determine whether class certification provides defendants with a real opportunity to test the merits of a securities class action,” she added. “Historically, class certification was viewed as sort of a fait accompli after the Supreme Court adopted the fraud-on-the-market theory,” Ms. Melvin explained. “Now that the courts, including the 2nd Circuit and not just the 5th Circuit, are conducting a more rigorous analysis of the Rule 23 class certification requirements, class certification has become another potential tipping point in a securities class action cases,” she concluded.

Read Time: 1 min

Practice Areas


Maria Woehr Aronson
Director of Communications

Molly Peterson
Senior Communications Manager

Jump to top of page

Necessary Cookies

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may disable these by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Analytical Cookies

Analytical cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.